Worklife

Ramblings about workplace culture, life in Japan, and then some.

Translation

Apr 26, 2004 20:07 pm / 2 comments

I was com­ment­ing all books com­ing out should at least have e-book ver­sion, because if a book was in data form, trans­la­tion soft­ware can be used to trans­late any­thing, and it would pro­mote bet­ter under­stand­ing of atti­tude of a cul­ture on cer­tain top­ics. My friend dis­agreed whole heart­edly. He said, even work­ing with the best of trans­la­tors, ideas and expla­na­tions are often mis-translated, and that is trans­la­tion from one Latin lan­guage to another. E-book, there­fore, could not even be idea pro­vok­ing source. Worse, it would give illu­sion to read­ers that they under­stand the think­ing or atti­tude other coun­try has on cer­tain topic.

Okay, I agree with that.

Mar­ket­ing research, off shoring, it is so easy to fall into the trap that we under­stand the other cul­ture through book learn­ing. We are read­ing stuff that is never 100% reli­able. How do we become cer­tain? Only through real com­mu­ni­ca­tion with real people.

 

Possibly Related


 

2 Comments

You can leave a comment, or trackback from your own site.

 
1. Shanx said on Jan 15, 2012 10:48 am:

You wrote this sev­eral years ago, and I found it now while search­ing some­thing on this topic on Google. Funny, that :)

Very true. Lan­guage has a lot of nuances devel­oped over cen­turies. Soft­ware can only go so far. It’s not too bad in shared-roots lan­guages like Span­ish or Ital­ian, which have a lot in com­mon with Eng­lish. But Chi­nese, Japan­ese, Korean, Indian languages–software is not even close.


 
2. Fuji said on Mar 17, 2012 19:40 pm:

Hi Shanx! Thank you for your com­ment. I see what you mean by shared-roots lan­guages. Do you think shared roots in writ­ing is eas­i­est to rec­og­nize? I find it fas­ci­nat­ing that some of Asian writ­ten lan­guages have one form in Chi­nese, yet they are mixed with each country’s own writ­ing sym­bol sys­tem. Hangeul in Korea, hiragana/katakana in Japan.


 

Leave a comment



More

« | »



Page 1 of 11